UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
)
)
v, )
No.
Violations: Title 18,
United Stales Code,
WILLIAM A. HANHARDT, ) Sections
371, 1962(d),
JOSEPH N. BASINSKI, ) 2314
and 2315.
PAUL ,I. SCHIRO,
)
SAM DESTEFANO, )
BUY ALTOBELLO, and )
WILLIAM R. BROWN.
)
COUNT ONE
The
SPECIAL JANUARY 1999-1 GRAND JURY charges:
1. At
all times material to this indictment:
(a) From July 13, 1953,
until his retirement on pension as a captain on March 26, 1986, defendant
WILLIAM A. HANHARDT was employed by the Chicago police Department (CPD"),
and held several supervisory positions,
including Chief of
Detectives, Chief of Traffic, Commander of the Burglary Section, Deputy
Superintendent for the Bureau of Inspectional Services, and District Commander.
For a portion of the period of the indictment until the date of the indictment,
defendant HANHARDT resided at 835 Heather Road, Deerfield, Illinois.
(b) Defendant GUY
ALTOBELLO was employed by
Altobello Jewelers, Inc., a retail jewelry store located at 100 East Roosevelt
Road, Store 19, Villa Park, Illinois. ALTOBELLO's duties included meeting with
traveling wholesale jewelry salespersons to
discuss,
examine and make wholesale purchases from their jewelry lines. (c) The Hyatt
Corporation was an Illinois corporation. Among other things, it operated the
Hyatt Regency Columbus Hotel at 350 North High Street, Columbus, Ohio, which
was near the Greater Columbus Convention Center, providing accommodations to
travelers. As a service to its guests, the Hyatt provided the use of safety
deposit boxes located in a room near the registration desk. (d) In August 1994,
the Greater Columbus Convention Center hosted the 1994 Mid-America Jewelry
Show. Many of the attending jewelers stayed at the Hyatt Regency Columbus
Hotel. The following entities, which engaged in and had activities that
affected interstate commerce, sent representatives to the 1994 Mid-America
Jewelry Show, and had representatives who utilized safety deposit boxes at the
Hyatt Regency Columbus Hotel: (i) Topaz Diamonds, Inc., a New York corporation,
was located at 580 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York. (ii) World Diamond
Imports, Ltd., and D&R J7jamond
Importers, Inc., were Arizona corporations that were located at 6900 East
Camelback Road, Scottsdale, Arizona. (iii.) Ragar Company was a partnership in
New Jersey. (iv) Jewel-Que, Inc., doing business as Jeweltique, was a New York
corporation located at 15 West 47th Street, New York, New York.
2
(v) M.B.
Saxon Co., Inc., was an Ohio corporation.
(vi) Ross & Shech7-er
Diamonds Ltd., doing business as Genesis II, was a New York corporation located
at 580 5°° Avenue, Suite 911, New York, New York.
(vii) Marsha's
14 Karat Gold Jewelry, was a sole
proprietorship located in Ohio.
(viii) The Gemological
Institute of America was a nonprofit educational organization of the jewelry
industry in the United States.
(e) The following
entities were all also involved in the jewelry industry and were engaged in and
had activities that affected interstate commerce:
(i) Baume & Mercier,
Inc. was a corporation organized and existing
under the laws of Switzerland. Its subsidiary, Baume & Mercier, was a
Division of VLG North America, Inc., located at 663 Fifth Avenue, New York, New
York.
(ii) Nafco Gems, Ltd.
("Nafco") was an Arizona corporation located in Scottsdale, Arizona.
(iii) Mayfield's Company
was an Arizona corporation located in Scottsdale, Arizona.
(iv) Mikan, Inc., was a
Delaware corporation located in Miami, Florida. Mikan, Inc. also had an office
in Israel.
3
(v) Dennis D. Naughton Jewelers, doing
business as Naughton Jewelers, was an Arizona corporation located at 37.72 Camelback
Road, Phoenix, Arizona.
(vi) Gaston Jewelers Inc.
was an Arizona corporation located at 3602 West Hell Road, Glendale, Arizona.
(vii) Golden Rule Jewelers, Inc., doing
business as "Jewelry by Albert," was an Arizona corporation. After
August 22, 1996, it was located at 8220 North Hayden Road, Suite 111. Before
August 22, 1996, it was located at 8180 North Hayden Road, Suite lo2D,
Scottsdale, Arizona.
(viii) Smith Fine
Jewelers, Inc. was an Arizona corporation. After October 1997, it was located
at 7704 East Doubletree
. Ranch
Road, Scottsdale, Arizona. Before October 1997 it was
located at 8989 East Via Linda, Suite
106, Scottsdale,
Arizona.
(ix) Molina, Inc., doing business as
Molina Fine Jewelers, was
an Arizona corporation located at 3134
East Camelback Road,
Phoenix, Arizona.
(x) Elan Ltd. was located at 589 5`h Avenue, Suite 1501, New
York, New York.
(xi) Kobi Katz, Inc., doing business as
Baguette World, was a
California corporation located at 640
South Hill Street, Suite
851, Los Angeles, California.
4
(xii) Lieber & Solow Ltd. was a Delaware
corporation located at 1140 Avenue of Americas, New York, New York.
(xiii) ESY, Inc. was a
New York corporation located at 30 West 47 `h Street,
Suite 601, New York, New York.
(xiv) Yahalom Inc., doing
business as Baguettes USA, was a California corporation located at 550 South
Hill Street, Suite 725, Los Angeles, California.
(xv) J. Schliff and Sons,
Inc., doing business as Gem Platinum Manufacturing Company (hereafter "Gem
Platinum") was a New York corporation located at 48 West 48`" Street,
New York, New York.
(xvi) Solar Diamonds,
Inc, was a New York corporation located at 580 5th Avenue, New York, New York.
(xvii) Advanced Ring
Manufacturing Company through 1986 was a company located at 145 West 45th Street, New York, New York.
(xviii) Oscar Heyman
& Brothers, Inc., was a New York corporation located at 501 Madison Avenue,
15th Floor, New York, New York.
(xix) DeBella Fine Gems
and Jewelry was a New Mexico corporation located at 100 East
Palace Avenue, Santa Fe, New Mexico.
(xx) .Rolex
Watch USA, Inc., was a New York corporation
located at 665 5th Avenue, New York,
New York.
(xxi) Horizon
Imports was an Illinois corporation located
at
5 south Wabash, Chicago,
Illinois.
(xxii) H,
K. Ma11ak, Inc., was a New York corporation located
in Great Neck, New York.
(xxiii) Phillip
Wolman & Co. was a California corporation
located at 550 South Hill Street, Los Angeles,
California.
(xxiv) Gordon Brothers Corporation was a Massachusetts
corporation
located at 40 Broad Street, Boston, Massachusetts.
(f)
From January 31, 1996, through February 6, 1996, the
American Gem Trade Association
("AGTA") held its annual convention
at the Tucson Convention Center, in
Tucson, Arizona. This
convention was open only to members of
the Association, not to the
general public. From February 7, 1996
through February 11, 1996,
the Tucson Gem and Mineral Society held
its trade show at the
Tucson Convention Center which the
trade show was open to the
general public. Throughout the same two
week period, several
hotels in Tucson, including the Holiday
Inn at 181 West Broadway,
Tucson, Arizona, held smaller jewelry
shows,.
(g) From May 29, 1996,
through June 4, 1996, the jewelers Circular Keystone ("JCK") held its
annual JCK International Jewelry Show at the Sands Expo and Convention Center
in Las Vegas, Nevada. This show was open to members of the jewelry trade only,
not to the general public.
5
(h) The
Great Lakes Jewelry Show took place on August 24 and 25, 1996, at the Marriott
Lincolnshire, Lincolnshire, Illinois.
7. THE ENTERPRISE
2. At all times material
to this indictment, there existed a criminal organization, i.e. a group of
individuals consisting of defendants WILLIAM A. HANHARDT,
JOSEPH N. BASINSKI, PAUL J. SCHIRO, SAM
DESTEFANO, GUY ALTOBELLO and others known and unknown, including James
D'Antonio and Robert Paul, both now deceased. This group of individuals associated
together for the purpose of engaging in an organized plan and scheme to gather
information on individuals involved in the jewelry industry for the purpose of
committing thefts of jewelry and disposing of the stolen jewelry, at times
gathering such information
from law enforcement and commercial databases by utilizing intrastate and
interstate wire communications- This group of individuals, hereinafter known as
"the enterprise," constituted an "enterprise" as that term
is used in Title 18, United States Code, Section 1961(4), that is, a group of
individuals associated in fact, which enterprise was engaged in and the
activities of which affected interstate commerce.
3. The enterprise existed primarily to
provide inC6me t6 certain of its members through illegal
activities.
4. In
order to carry out its activities, the enterprise utilized individuals employed
by and associated with it who had
7
varying roles and responsibilities. The
roles and responsibilities
were
as follows:
DEFENDANT
WILLIAM A. HANHARDT
(a) Defendant
WILLIAM A. HANFLARDT (hereafter "HANHARDT^), was the leader of the enterprise. In
that capacity he supervised codefendant JOSEPH N. HASINSKI and together they directed the
activities of others employed by and associated with the enterprise- HANHARDT
directed the other
defendants and others in their gathering of information on potential jewelry
theft victims and the surveillance of several such individuals. He utilized
certain CPD officers to do database searches of CPD and other law enforcement
computers to obtain information concerning jewelry salespersons. Similarly, he
caused a private investigator to conduct credit bureau database searches and
other database searches to gather information concerning individuals who were traveling
jewelry salespersons. At times, HANHARDT used the telephone at his residence at
835 Heather Road, Deerfield, Illinois, to direct certain defendants and others
to further the interests of the enterprise. HANHARDT personally participated in the theft of
jewelry.
DEFENDANT
JOSEPH N. BASINSKI
(b) Defendant JOSEPH
N. BASINSKI (hereafter "BASINSKI")
served the enterprise by
identifying potential targets for the enterprise, including owners of or
salespersons to jewelry stores
8
or businesses, by physical
surveillances, telephone calls, database searches 'and other means. He would
physically follow and surveill potential victims or locations for the purpose
of stealing high quality jewelry. He assisted the enterprise by directing and
assisting in directing the activities
of one or more of his codefendants in accomplishing the aims of the enterprise,
including directing their activities on physical surveillances of locations and
individuals and also the actual theft of jewelry. He also served the enterprise
by maintaining information an potential victims of the enterprise and certain
tools and instrumentalities of the enterprise, BASINSKI personally participated
in the theft of jewelry.
DEFENDANT
PAUL J. SCHIRO
(c) Defendant PAUL J.
SCHIRO (hereafter "SCHIR0") served the enterprise by, among other
things, conducting physical surveillances of jewelry stores, jewelry shows,
owners of jewelry stores, and jewelry salespersons. SCHIRO personally
participated in the theft of jewelry.
DEFENDANT
SAM DESTEFANO
(d) Defendant SAM
DESTEFANO (hereafter
"DESTEFANO") served the enterprise by, among other things, conducting
physical surveillances of jewelry stores, owners of jewelry stores, and jewelry
salespersons. DESTEPANO personally participated in the theft of jewelry.
9
(e) Defendant
GUY ALTOBELLO (hereafter "ALTOBELLO)
served the enterprise by providing one
or more of his co-defendants with information concerning jewelry salespersons that
conducted business with Altobello Jewelers, Inc., so that certain of his codefendants
could further identify such persons and determine the most opportune occasion
to steal jewelry from such persons.
JAMES
D'ANTONIO
(f) Until his death in
December 1993, James D'Antonio was a coconspirator and served the enterprise
by, among other things, maintaining information of traveling jewelry
salespersons and maintaining various tools and instrumentalities . of the
enterprise.
ROBERT PAUL
(g) Robert Paul, now
deceased, was a coconspirator and served the enterprise by conducting physical
surveillance of jewelry stores and jewelry salespersons in Arizona and by
providing a cellular telephone used by his coconspirators.
10
II. THE RACKETEERING CONSPIRACY
S. Beginning in or about
the early 19BOS and continuing thereafter to in or about April 1998, the exact
dates being to the Grand Jury unknown, at Chicago in the Northern District of
Illinois, Eastern Division, and elsewhere,
WILLIAM A. HANHARDT,
JOSEPH
N. HASINSKI,
PAUL J. SCHIRO,
SAM DESTEFANO, and GUY ALTOBELLO,
defendants herein, being persons
employed by and associated with an enterprise, that is, the enterprise as
described in Paragraph 2 above, which enterprise engaged in, and the activities
of which affected, interstate commerce, did knowingly conspire together and
with other persons known and unknown to the grand jury, to conduct and
participate, directly and indirectly, in the conduct of the affairs of the
enterprise through a pattern of racketeering activity as those terms are
defined in Title 18, United States Code, Section 1961 (1),in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 1962(c), as
further specified in
Paragraphs 6 and 7 below,
6. The
racketeering activity consisted of:
(a) Transportation of
stolen goods of the value of $5000 or more in interstate commerce, in violation
of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2314.
(b) Receipt, possession,
concealment, storage, sale and disposal of stolen goods of the value of $5,000
or more, which had
11
crossed a state boundary after being
stolen, knowing the same to have been stolen, in violation of 'title 18, United
States Code, Section 2315.
7. As part of the conspiracy, each of the
defendants and others agreed that a Conspirator would commit at least two acts
of racketeering in the conduct of the affairs of the enterprise.
III. MANNER AND MEANS OF THE CONSPIRACY
8. Among
the manner and means of the conspiracy agreed to by the defendants and others,
were the following:
(a) It was part of the
conspiracy that one or more of the conspirators would and did steal jewelry and
cause-some or all of said jewelry to be transported in interstate commerce,
including the following:
1) The
theft from the vehicle of a salesperson for
Baume & Mercier, -Inc., of
approximately 180 watches
having a total value of approximately
$310,000 in
Glendale, Wisconsin, on October 8,
1984.
2) The
theft from the vehicle of a salesperson for
Rolex Watch USA, Inc., of watches
having a value of
approximately $500,000 on or about
October 13,
1986, in Monterey, California.
3) The
theft from the vehicle of a salesperson for
Gordon Brothers Corporation of jewelry
having a
value of approximately $125,000 in
Englewood, Ohio,
on or about August 28, 1989.
4) The
theft of a bag of a salesperson for J. Schliff
and Sons, Inc., doing business as Gem
Platinum
Manufacturing, containing jewelry
having a value of
approximately $1,000,000 on or about
June 30, 1992,
at Dallas/Ft. Worth, Texas.
5) The theft from the rental vehicle of a
salesperson
for
J. Schliff and Sons, Inc., doing business as
Gem Platinum Manufacturing, of jewelry
having a
value of in excess of $1,000,000 in
Flat Rock,
Michigan, on June 23, 1993.
6) The
theft from the rental vehicle of a salesperson
for H.K. Ma11ak, Inc., of jewelry
having a value of
approximately $240,000 on August 3, 1993, in
Mankato, Minnesota.
7) The
theft from representatives for Nafco Gems, Ltd.
and Mayfield's Company of jewelry
having a value in
excess of $170,000 at the Skyharbor
Airport,
Phoenix, Arizona, on May 7, 1994.
e) The theft
from safety deposit boxes at the Hyatt
Regency .Hotel, Columbus, Ohio, of
jewelry,
gemstones, U.S. currency, and other
material of an
aggregate value in excess of $1,500,000
on August
27, 1994. The victims of such theft
included the
various entities listed in Paragraph
1(e) of this
Count.
(b) It was further a part
of the conspiracy that one or more of the conspirators would and did attempt to
steal and remove jewelry from persons involved in the jewelry trade, including
the following:
1) The
theft from a hotel room at the Los Angeles
Airport Hilton of the suitcase of a
salesperson for
Solar Diamonds, Inc. on or about June
17, 1994, in
Los Angeles, California.
2) The
theft from the vehicle of a salesperson for
Baume & Mercier, Inc., of two
jewelry cases on
October 2, 1996, one of which contained
numerous
fine watches, in Chesterton, Indiana,
as more fully
described in Count Two.
(c) It was further part
of the conspiracy that one or more of the conspirators would and did physically
surveill the residences, places of work, and/or the persons of individuals the
conspirators believed to be involved in
the jewelry trade, including the following:
1) A
Nafco Gems, Ltd. representative, his residence,
his car and/or place of business in
Arizona on
various occasions, including in 1995
and 1996.
2) A
jewelry appraiser, his car and/or residence in
Arizona on various occasions including
in February
and March 1996.
3) A
Mayfield's Company representative, her car,
residence and/or place of business in
Arizona and
elsewhere including in 1996.
4) A
Baume & Mercier salesperson, his car and/or
residence in Illinois, Wisconsin, and Indiana
on
several occasions, including between
April 1996 and
October 1996, as more fully described
in Count Two.
S) A
Kobi Katz, Inc./Lieber Solow, Ltd.
salesperson's residence in Illinois in
August 1996.
(d) It was a part of the
conspiracy that, to generate income, certain of the conspirators attempted to
identify traveling jewelry salespersons and to obtain personal information on
each such salesperson for the purpose of
determining the most opportune time and occasion to steal from a car, hotel
room, or other location, jewelry being transported by the salesperson.
(e) It was further part
of the conspiracy that one or more of the conspirators would arid did contact
hotels and determine if a traveling jewelry salesperson was staying or was
scheduled to stay at the hotel, including defendant HANHARDT contacting three
hotels in Illinois on August 23, 1996, to
determine if a certain Elan Ltd. salesperson had an advanced reservation, and
defendant
14
DESTEFANO contacting numerous hotels in
Minnesota on August 2-3, 1993, to determine the location of a certain H.K.
Mallak, Inc., salesperson.
(f) It was further part
of the conspiracy that one or more of the conspirators received information
from defendant ALTOBELLO concerning, among other things, the identity of
certain traveling jewelry salespersons, the nature and quality of their jewelry
and/or a portion of the travel schedule of the traveling jewelry salespersons,
including in 1996 a Mikan, Inc. salesperson and an ESY, Inc. salesperson.
(g) It was further a part
of the conspiracy that, to facilitate the activities of the enterprise, certain
of the coconspirators obtained, maintained and used communications equipment
such as walkie talkies, pagers, skypagers and cellular telephones.
(h) It was further a part
of the conspiracy that, to perpetuate the enterprise, certain of the
conspirators used and agreed to use money obtained from the pattern of
racketeering activity in the operation of the enterprise.
(i) It was further a part
of the conspiracy one or more of the conspirators, including defendants
AANHARDT, HASINSKI, and SCHIRO, would and did physically surveill jewelry
stores as part of a plan and scheme to identify persons that would carry
jewelry to and from such jewelry stores, including the following:
15
1) Dennis D. Naughton Jewelers, doing
business as
Naughton
Jewelers, and Molina, Inc., doing business
as Molina Fine Jewelers, in Phoenix,
Arizona, on
numerous occasions during the years
1995 and 1996.
2) Golden
Rule Jewelers, Inc. doing business as
Jewelry
by Albert, in Scottsdale, Arizona, on