|
|
U.S. District Court Northern District of Illinois (Chicago) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 93-CV-6129 Stevens, et al v. Loverde, et al Filed: 10/08/93 Assigned to: Hon. James B. Zagel Jury demand: Defendant Demand: $50,000 Nature of Suit: 350 Lead Docket: None Jurisdiction: Diversity Dkt# in other court: None Cause: 28:1332 Diversity-Auto Negligence LAURA ASHLEY STEVENS Timothy F. Kelly
plaintiff [COR LD NTC A]
Timothy F. Kelly & Associates
9250 Colombia Avenue
Suite 2A
Munster, IN 46321
(219) 836-4062
Harvey Karlovac
[COR]
Attorney
3419 North Elaine Place
Apartment 1-E
Chicago, IL 60657
(312) 975-8468
MICHAEL STEVENS Timothy F. Kelly
plaintiff [term 01/19/94]
[term 01/19/94] (See above)
[COR LD NTC A]
Harvey Karlovac
[term 01/19/94]
(See above)
[COR]
TERRY JEAN JOHNSON Timothy F. Kelly
plaintiff [term 01/19/94]
[term 01/19/94] (See above)
[COR LD NTC A]
Harvey Karlovac
[term 01/19/94]
(See above)
[COR]
G BURNHAM LANMAN, III Timothy F. Kelly
plaintiff [term 01/19/94]
[term 01/19/94] (See above)
[COR LD NTC A]
Harvey Karlovac
[term 01/19/94]
(See above)
[COR]
ANTHONY STEVENS Timothy F. Kelly
plaintiff (See above)
[COR LD NTC A]
Harvey Karlovac
(See above)
[COR]
v.
CHARLES V LOVERDE Joseph Jude O'Connell
defendant [COR LD NTC A]
Deborah Rusoff O'Brien
[COR]
Richard J. Juarez
[COR]
Hinshaw & Culbertson
222 North LaSalle Street
Suite 300
Chicago, IL 60601-1081
(312) 704-3000
LABORERS INTERNATIONAL UNION Joseph Jude O'Connell
OF NORTH AMERICA, Headquarters [term 06/30/94]
defendant (See above)
[term 06/30/94] [COR]
Deborah Rusoff O'Brien
(See above)
[COR]
Richard J. Juarez
[term 06/30/94]
(See above)
[COR]
Martha Ann Pagliari
[term 06/30/94]
[COR]
Cassiday, Schade & Gloor
333 West Wacker Drive
Suite 1200
Chicago, IL 60606-1289
(312)641-3100
Richard A. Barrett, Jr.
[term 06/30/94]
[COR LD NTC A]
Cassiday, Schade & Gloor
128 South County Farm Road
Suite 128B
Wheaton, IL 60187
(708) 682-9800
DATE # DOCKET ENTRY
10/8/93 1 COMPLAINT - Civil cover sheet - Appearance(s) of Timothy
F. Kelly as attorney(s) for plaintiff(s) ( three originals
and three copies summons(es) issued.) ( Documents: 1-1
through 1-2) (ps) [Entry date 10/12/93]
10/8/93 -- RECEIPT regarding payment of filing fee paid; on 10/8/93 in
the amount of $ 120.00, receipt # 423870. (ps)
[Entry date 10/12/93]
10/12/93 -- MAILED 3.13 and 3.14 letters to plaintiffs counsel. (ps)
10/14/93 2 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for plaintiffs by Timotny F. Kelly and
Harvey Karlovac (tlm)
10/27/93 3 RULE 39 Affidavit of Timothy F. Kelly (rm)
[Entry date 10/29/93]
10/27/93 4 RULE 39 Affidavit of Harvey Karlovac (rm)
[Entry date 10/29/93]
11/1/93 5 MEMORANDUM of law by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA in
support of its motion to dismiss plaintiffs' complaint;
Notice of filing. (rm) [Entry date 11/02/93]
11/1/93 6 ANSWER to complaint by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA (rm)
[Entry date 11/02/93]
11/2/93 7 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendant Laborers Intl Un NA by
Richard A. Barrett Jr., Martha Ann Pagliari (rm)
[Entry date 11/03/93]
11/2/93 8 RULE 39 Affidavit of Richard A. Barrett Jr., Martha Ann
Pagliari (rm) [Entry date 11/03/93]
11/9/93 9 MOTION by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA to dismiss counts
III thru X of the complaint; Notice of motion. (rm)
[Entry date 11/12/93]
11/9/93 10 MINUTE ORDER of 11/9/93 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Answer
brief to motion to dismiss counts III thru X of the
complaint [9-1] due 11/30/93. Reply to answer brief due
12/14/93 Status hearing set for 1/14/94 at 10:00 a.m.
Mailed notice (rm) [Entry date 11/12/93]
11/15/93 -- SUMMONS (2 originals and 2 copies) issued as to defendants
(rm) [Entry date 11/16/93]
11/22/93 11 ANSWER to plaintiff's complaint at law by defendants; jury
demand (Attachment). (rm) [Entry date 12/01/93]
11/23/93 12 MOTION by defendants for an order granting them leave to
file their appearance and jury demand and to vacate any
and all defaults entered against the defendants and to
extend time within which to answer or otherwise plead to
and including 12/21/93; Notice of motion. (rm)
[Entry date 12/01/93]
11/23/93 13 MINUTE ORDER of 11/23/93 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Granting
defendants' motion for an order granting them leave to file
their appearance [12-1], jury demand [12-2], to vacate any
and all defaults entered against the defendants [12-3] and
to extend time within which to answer or otherwise plead to
and including 12/21/93 [12-4]. No notice (rm)
[Entry date 12/01/93]
11/23/93 14 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendants by Joseph Jude
O'Connell, Richard J. Juarez (rm) [Entry date 12/01/93]
11/23/93 15 RULE 39 Affidavit of Richard J. Juarez (rm)
[Entry date 12/01/93]
11/23/93 16 RULE 39 Affidavit of Joseph Jude O'Connell (rm)
[Entry date 12/01/93]
11/30/93 17 RESPONSE by plaintiffs to motion to dismiss counts III thru
of the complaint of Laborers Inernational Union of North
America [9-1]; Notice of filing. (rm) [Entry date 12/07/93]
12/14/93 18 REPLY by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA in support of its
motion to dismiss counts III thru X of plaintiff's
complaint [9-1]; Notice of filing. (rm)
[Entry date 12/15/93]
12/20/93 19 SUPPLEMENT by plaintiffs to response to motion to dismiss
of defendant, Laborers International Union of North America
(Exhibit); Notice of filing. (rm) [Entry date 12/21/93]
1/14/94 20 MINUTE ORDER of 1/14/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing reset for 2/4/94 at 10:00 a.m. Motion to dismiss
counts III thru X of the complaint [9-1] is taken under
advisement. Mailed notice (rm) [Entry date 01/18/94]
1/19/94 21 MEMORANDUM, OPINION, AND ORDER (ksl) [Entry date 01/20/94]
1/19/94 22 MINUTE ORDER of 1/19/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Granting
in part and denying in part motion to dismiss counts III
thru X of the complaint [9-1]. Counts III, IV, V, VI, IX
and X are dismissed. Plaintiffs G Burnham Lanman, Terry
Jean Johnson, and Michael Stevens are dismissed from the
case. Further, the motion in the alternative for leave to
amend the complaint is denied. Mailed notice (ksl)
[Entry date 01/20/94]
2/2/94 23 ANSWER to count VIII of plaintiff's complaint by defendant
Laborers Intl Un NA; Notice of filing (vs)
[Entry date 02/03/94]
2/4/94 24 MINUTE ORDER of 2/4/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing held; continued to 5/6/94 at 10:00 am. Discovery
closed 5/6/94 No notice (cmf) [Entry date 02/11/94]
4/5/94 25 MOTION by plaintiffs' for extension of discovery cut off.
(vj) [Entry date 04/14/94]
4/5/94 26 MOTION by plaintiffs' for attorney Timothy F. Kelly to
appear pro hac vice. (vj) [Entry date 04/14/94]
4/5/94 27 NOTICE of motion by plaintiffs' regarding motion for
extension of discovery cut off [25-1] and for attorney
Timothy F. Kelly to appear pro hac vice [26-1]. (vj)
[Entry date 04/14/94]
4/11/94 28 MINUTE ORDER of 4/11/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel: Status
hearing reset for 29 Jul 94 at 10:00 a.m. Granting
plaintiffs' motion for extension of discovery cut off
[25-1]. Close of discovery extended to July 29, 1994.
Granting plaintiffs' motion for attorney Timothy F. Kelly
to appear pro hac vice [26-1]. Status set for May 6, 1994
is stricken. Mailed notice (vj) [Entry date 04/14/94]
6/30/94 29 MOTION by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA for summary
judgment (Exhibit) (is) [Entry date 07/01/94]
6/30/94 30 NOTICE of motion by defendant Laborers Intl Un NA regarding
motion for summary judgment [29-1] (is)
[Entry date 07/01/94]
6/30/94 31 MINUTE ORDER of 6/30/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Denying
defendant, the Laborers' International Union of North
America's motion for summary judgment as moot [29-1].
Defendant the Laborers' International Union of North
America is dismissed as a defendant. terminating party
Laborers Intl Un NA Mailed notice (is) [Entry date 07/01/94]
7/29/94 32 MINUTE ORDER of 7/29/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing held; continued to 10/21/94 at 10:00 a.m. Close of
discovery set for 09/15/94. Leave is granted to file an
additional appearance. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 08/03/94]
7/29/94 33 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendant Charles V Loverde,
defendant Laborers Intl Un NA by Deborah Rusoff O'Brien
(jmp) [Entry date 08/03/94]
7/29/94 34 RULE 39 Affidavit of Deborah Rusoff O'Brien (jmp)
[Entry date 08/03/94]
8/19/94 35 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde, defendant Laborers
Intl Un NA for summary judgment (jmp) [Entry date 08/22/94]
8/19/94 36 MEMORANDUM OF LAW by defendant Charles V Loverde, defendant
Laborers Intl Un NA in support of motion for summary
judgment [35-1] (jmp) [Entry date 08/22/94]
8/19/94 37 RULE 12(M) Statement of material facts as to which
defendant Charles V Loverde, defendant Laborers Intl Un NA
contend there is no genuine issue of material fact in
support of their motion for summary judgment against
plaintiffs (Exhibits) (jmp) [Entry date 08/22/94]
8/31/94 38 MOTION by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff Anthony
Stevens to bar plaintiffs' experts (Exhibits) (jmp)
[Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 39 RESPONSE by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff
Anthony Stevens to motion to bar plaintiffs' experts [38-1]
(Exhibits) (jmp) [Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 40 NOTICE of filing by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens,
plaintiff Anthony Stevens regarding motion response to
defendants' motion to bar plaintiffs' experts [39-1] (jmp)
[Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 41 MOTION by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff Anthony
Stevens to compel (Exhibits) (jmp) [Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 42 CERTIFICATE of compliance with Local General Rule 12(K) by
plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff Anthony Stevens
(Exhibits) (jmp) [Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 43 NOTICE of motion by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens,
plaintiff Anthony Stevens regarding motion to compel
[41-1], regarding certificate of compliance with Local
General Rule 12(K) [42-1] (jmp) [Entry date 09/07/94]
8/31/94 44 MINUTE ORDER of 8/31/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Denying
motion to bar plaintiffs' experts [38-1] without prejudice.
Denying motion to compel [41-1] as moot. Answer brief to
motion for summary judgment [35-1] due 09/21/94. Reply to
answer brief due 10/05/94. Status hearing set for 10/21/94
to stand. Mailed notice (jmp) [Entry date 09/07/94]
9/12/94 45 TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following date(s):
07/29/94. Before Honorable James B. Zagel (jmp)
[Entry date 09/13/94]
9/21/94 46 RESPONSE and memorandum of law in response by plaintiff
Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff Anthony Stevens to motion
for summary judgment [35-1] (jmp) [Entry date 09/22/94]
9/21/94 47 RULE 12(N) RESPONSE to Rule l12(M) statement of material
facts of defendants Charles V. Loverde, Jr. and Local 1092
of the Laborer's International Union of North America in
support of their motion for summary judgment by plaintiff
Laura Ashley Stevens, plaintiff Anthony Stevens
(Attachments) (jmp) [Entry date 09/22/94]
9/21/94 48 NOTICE of filing by plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens,
plaintiff Anthony Stevens regarding response to Rule 12(M)
statement of material facts of defendants Charles V.
Loverde, Jr. and Local 1092 of the Laborer's International
Union of North America in support of their motion for
summary judgment [47-1] (jmp) [Entry date 09/22/94]
10/5/94 49 REPLY by defendant Charles V Loverde, defendant Laborers
Intl Un NA in support of motion for summary judgment [35-1]
(Orig. dkt. 10/06/94) (jmp) [Entry date 10/12/94]
10/21/94 50 MINUTE ORDER of 10/21/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing held; continued to 11/04/94 at 10:00 a.m. Motion
for summary judgment [35-1] is taken under advisement. No
notice (jmp) [Entry date 10/26/94]
10/28/94 51 MINUTE ORDER of 10/28/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Granting
motion for summary judgment [29-1]. Denying motion for
summary judgment [35-1] (See reverse of minute order)
Mailed notice (jmp) [Entry date 11/01/94]
11/4/94 52 MINUTE ORDER of 11/4/94 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing held. Pretrial conference set for 01/10/95 at 4:00
p.m. Trial set for 01/16/95 at 10:30 a.m. Final pretrial
order due 01/05/95. Mailed notice (jmp)
[Entry date 11/08/94]
1/10/95 53 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine for an
order to bar parties from bringing to the attention of the
jury evidence regarding the size of the law firm of Hinshaw
& Culbertson ; (jmp) [Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 54 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde to bar testimony of
plaintiffs' accident reconstruction expert ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 55 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine for an
order to barring the plaintiffs from mentioning any
evidence or information regarding Ms. Stevens' medical
condition ; (jmp) [Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 56 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine to exclude
evidence of defendant's medical condition ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 57 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine for an
order barring witnesses from the courtroom while the trial
is in progress ; (jmp) [Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 58 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine to exclude
evidence of prior traffic citations ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 59 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine for an
order prohibiting the plaintiffs' from mentioning any
information or evidence regarding the fact that the
defendant is protected by insurance ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 60 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde to bifurcate issues
of liability and damages for purposes of trial ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 61 MOTION by defendant Charles V Loverde in limine for an
order prohibiting the plaintiffs from bringing attention to
the defendant's financial status ; (jmp)
[Entry date 01/18/95]
1/10/95 62 MINUTE ORDER of 1/10/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Pretrial
conference held. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/18/95]
1/13/95 63 MINUTE ORDER of 1/13/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Status
hearing held. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/17/95 64 MINUTE ORDER of 1/17/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Jury
trial held; continued to 01/18/95 at 9:00 a.m. Jury trial
begins. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/18/95 65 MINUTE ORDER of 1/18/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Jury
trial held; continued to 01/19/5 at 10:30 a.m. Both sides
rest. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/19/95 66 MINUTE ORDER of 1/19/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Jury
trial held and concluded. Closing argument made. Jury
deliberations begin. No notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/19/95 67 JURY INSTRUCTIONS given (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/19/95 68 JURY VERDICT for defendant Charles V Loverde against
plaintiff Laura Ashley Stevens (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/19/95 69 MINUTE ORDER of 1/19/95 by Hon. James B. Zagel : Enter
judgment on jury verdict in favor of defendant Charles
Loverde and against plaintiff, Laura Ashley Stevens.
terminating case Mailed notice (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
1/19/95 70 ENTERED JUDGMENT (jmp) [Entry date 01/20/95]
Case Flags: TERMED GOTTSC END OF DOCKET: 1:93cv6129 |
|
IPSN © 1997-2006 All Rights reserved. Not for republication on the
internet without permission. |